Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Hysteria as a National Pastime

Opinion article by Tim Rutten:

"If you reengage the American media after a month out of the country, as I've done this week, it's hard not to conclude that hysteria is now the dominant characteristic of our politics and civic conversation."

For me, the money quote is down at the bottom of page 2:

"Back in the early 1970s — an era whose tumult we yet may come to regard as benign — social scientists here and in Britain coined the term "moral panic" to describe what can happen when groups of people are seized by an exaggerated fear that other people or communal forces threaten their values or way of life. The scholars described those who promoted the panic's spread as "moral entrepreneurs" — a term that takes on a deep resonance when you consider the commentators and politicians who have attached themselves, and their interests, to the "tea party" and its attendant movements.

"In the midst of moral panic, inchoate indignation stands in for reason; accusation and denunciation supplant dialogue and argument; history and facts are rendered malleable, merely adjuncts of the moral entrepreneur's — or should we say provocateur's — rhetorical will. As we now also see, a self-interested mass media with an economic stake in the theatricality of raised and angry voices can transmit moral panic like a pathogen.

"Looking around the United States in the summer of 2010, hysterical moral panic seems an apt description of our fevered political condition."

I recently commented that I don't really care whether or not other people watch television; my decision not to watch is personal, rather than ideological. That's still true, but I would like to encourage people to unplug themselves from the panic factories.

Edited to add: Just to be clear, I'm not talking about television in general; "panic factories" is a refence to the sort programming which is specifically designed to make people panic about things in the real world. News shows are pretty bad about this ("Could your kids be in danger because of this common household item? Tune in at eight to find out...") and I suspect that a fair chunk of talk/opinion shows are as well. There's some portion of the population whose churches are panic factories, and there's plenty of people whose friends are as well.

Basically, if something or someone spends most of their time telling you things that make you worried or scared, it's time to stop listening to them. A well-placed (and truthful) warning is one thing; a constant litany of reasons to panic is another. I'm talking about the American news media in particular, but I think it's good general advice.

4 comments:

  1. I think there's a distinct difference between me watching Spongebob Squarepants and someone watching Glen Beck...

    I understand your argument, but it smacks of the "Say No To Drugs" mentality. You can't lump the majority of what people watch (largely fictional dramas and comedies, or equally fictional reality TV) with the meth habit of watching Fox News.

    I can't even remember the last time I watched the news on TV... probably the same year I bought a newspaper because my internet wasn't connected in the apartment yet.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Actually, no: I don't think you do understand my argument. Where did I say that people shouldn't watch television?

    I said that I encourage people to "unplug themselves from the panic factories". That's not a term for television in general; it's a refence to the sort programming which is specifically designed to make people panic about things in the real world. News shows are pretty bad about this ("Could your kids be in danger because of this common household item? Tune in at eight to find out...") and I suspect that a fair chunk of talk/opinion shows are as well. There's some portion of the population whose churches are panic factories.

    Hm. Maybe that wasn't clear. ::goes off to edit the post::

    ReplyDelete
  3. *from under a bed sheet* Leave television alone!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Look, if I make the sign of the cross, and the media recoils, hissing, that is not my fault. Just sayin'...

    ReplyDelete

Feel free to leave comments; it lets me know that people are actually reading my blog. Interesting tangents and topic drift just add flavor. Linking to your own stuff is fine, as long as it's at least loosely relevant. Be civil, and have fun!